Today in News History
On July 13, several notable moments in the history of News stand out. In 1357, Bartolus de Saxoferrato Italian academic and jurist (born 1313) passed away. In 1919, William F. Quinn, American lawyer (died 2006) was born. In 1963, Neal Foulds, English snooker player and sportscaster was born. In 1973, Watergate scandal: Alexander Butterfield reveals the existence of a secret Oval Office taping system to investigators for the Senate Watergate Committee. In 1996, Pandro S. Berman, American director, producer, and production manager (born 1905) passed away. In 2013, Vernon B. Romney, American lawyer and politician, 14th Attorney General of Utah (born 1924) passed away. In 2013, Leonard Garment, American lawyer and public servant, 14th White House Counsel (born 1924) passed away. In 2015, Philipp Mißfelder, German historian and politician (born 1979) passed away. In 2024, Thomas Matthew Crooks, American student, known for attempting to assassinate former US President Donald Trump (born 2003) passed away. In 2024, President of the United States Donald Trump is injured in an assassination attempt while speaking at an election campaign rally near Butler, Pennsylvania. Together, these milestones provide historical context for today's news news and ongoing narratives.
Judge blasts Trump's IRS lawsuit as filed for 'improper purpose,' recommends attorney discipline

The ruling from U.S. District Judge Kathleen Williams amounts to a stinging rebuke of the Republican president's lawsuit, characterizing it as an exercise in self-dealing in which he sued an entity that is effectively under his control.
Narrative Intelligence Brief
This article was published by PBS NewsHour, a source frequently categorized with a lean left bias based in United States of America. Our narrative intelligence engine continuously monitors coverage from this outlet to track framing, bias, and rhetorical patterns. Our initial algorithmic scan of this specific piece did not flag high-confidence rhetorical techniques, suggesting a generally straightforward reporting style or neutral framing. By understanding the editorial perspective of PBS NewsHour, readers can better contextualize the information presented and compare it across our broader media matrix to find the real narrative.
More from PBS NewsHour
July 13, 2026
Minnesota prosecutors obtain long withheld evidence in probe into fatal shootings of Good, Pretti
July 13, 2026
Sen. Lindsey Graham's sudden death spurs false claims
July 13, 2026
ICE shot and killed a Colombian man in Maine. This is the 2nd time in a week the agency used deadly force
July 13, 2026
12 states challenge Paramount's takeover of Warner, say merger would 'extinguish competition'
July 13, 2026
Ukraine fears it will have a weaker link to Trump after Sen. Lindsey Graham's sudden death
Analysis Methodology
This narrative analysis was generated using the CoDataLab Global Intelligence Engine. Our proprietary AI scans thousands of cross-border sources to identify sentiment patterns, framing techniques, and potential media bias. While AI provides the data-driven foundation, our objective is to empower readers with additional context beyond the standard headline.The content displayed above is a structured summary designed for rapid information processing. For the full original report, please visit the source outlet.More Coverage
Discussion
"cup"
How other outlets are covering this story
Compare narratives across 36 related reports from 36 sources. Real Narrative News aggregates the coverage spectrum so you can see who emphasises what — bias tags reflect the outlet, not the story.
Coverage bias distribution
36 sources
Left 28%
Center 17%
Right 50%
Drudge Report
· Jul 13, 2026
Judge blasts Trump's IRS lawsuit as filed for 'improper purpose,' recommends attorney discipline...
Judge blasts Trump's IRS lawsuit as filed for 'improper purpose,' recommends attorney discipline... (First column, 1st story, link)
Fox News
· Jul 13, 2026
Obama-appointed judge torches Trump admin in latest courtroom showdown, refers attorney for Bar review
A federal judge ruled Trump's 10 billion IRS lawsuit over leaked confidential tax returns was for an improper purpose, referring attorneys for discipline.
Off The Press
· Jul 13, 2026
Judge says Trump sued IRS for ‘improper purpose,’ refers his lawyer to Florida bar
Afederal judge on Monday chastised President Donald Trump’s lawsuit against the IRS and referred the attorneys who brought it for disciplinary proceedings. Trump sued the IRS over the leak of his tax returns by then-contractor Charles Littlejohn, who pleaded guilty. The Department of Justice settled with the IRS earlier this year, reaching an agreement to []...Click to read more
DNyuz
· Jul 13, 2026
Trump’s words hurled back at him in scathing ruling as judge refers his lawyer to the bar
A federal judge ruled Monday that President Donald Trump’s 10 billion lawsuit against the IRS was an improper exercise in self-dealing, and barred him from claiming that the sweeping tax protections he walked away with came out of a legitimate settlement, the New York Times reported. Judge Kathleen M. Williams did not explicitly kill the []
Times of India
· Jul 13, 2026
US judge scraps Trump's IRS settlement deal, says lawsuit sought to 'manipulate judicial process'
A federal judge voided President Trump's settlement with the IRS. The lawsuit was deemed an improper attempt to manipulate the judicial process. Sanctions and disciplinary actions were recommended against involved lawyers. The judge found the parties were not truly opposing each other. The Justice Department was criticized for its role in the settlement.
PoliticusUSA
· Jul 13, 2026
Trump's IRS Lawsuit Ruled A Sham, and Judge Orders Sanctions Against His Lawyers
A federal judge has ruled that Trump's lawsuit against the IRS was a sham that was brought for an improper purpose, and the judge also ordered that Trump's lawyers be sanctioned and punished.
The Epoch Times
· Jul 13, 2026
Federal Judge Finds Trump IRS Suit Collusive, Improper
Judge Kathleen Williams also took disciplinary measures against two Trump attorneys.
KSAT San Antonio
· Jun 26, 2026
Mistrial declared after jury deadlocks in arson trial over deadly 2025 Palisades Fire in Los Angeles
A federal judge declared a mistrial Friday in the arson case against the man accused of sparking the deadly 2025 Palisades Fire in Los Angeles.
UPI
· Jul 13, 2026
Federal judge says Trump sued IRS for ‘improper purpose’
Federal judge says Trump sued IRS for ‘improper purpose’
BBC News
· Jul 13, 2026
US judge voids Donald Trump's $1.8bn settlement with IRS that gave him immunity from tax audits
The judge said the suit was brought for 'improper purposes' and referred a Trump attorney for possible disciplinary action.
Catholic World Report
· Jul 1, 2026
Supreme Court will hear Catholic-backed Jewish religious liberty suit involving ‘finality’ rule
Daniel Grand is asking the high court to rule on his long-running lawsuit against the city of University Heights, Ohio. [...]
PBS NewsHour
· Jun 22, 2026
Federal judge halts Trump administration effort to subpoena Walz in immigration enforcement probe
A federal judge has blocked an attempt by the Trump administration to subpoena Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz and other state officials, calling it an effort to harass and retaliate against them.
Knewz
· Jun 23, 2026
Trump admin loses in court as judge shuts down attempts to subpoena Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz, other Dem leaders in immigration crackdown dispute
A federal judge has delivered a major legal setback to the Trump administration, quashing six grand jury subpoenas issued by the Justice Department against Minnesota Governor Tim Walz, Attorney General Keith Ellison, Minneapolis Mayor Jacob Frey, St. Paul Mayor Kaohly Her, Hennepin County Attorney Mary Moriarty and officials from Hennepin and Ramsey counties. The ruling,...
Washington Examiner
· Jul 13, 2026
Judge bars Trump from using IRS immunity deal to evade investigation over past tax filings
A federal judge in Florida on Monday dealt a blow to President Donald Trump over his landmark settlement with the Internal Revenue Service, barring him from citing the case in any future attempt to avoid scrutiny over his past tax filings. U.S. District Judge Kathleen Williams, an appointee of former President Barack Obama, found that []
OpsLens
· Jul 9, 2026
‘Big win’: Joe Biden’s Judge Sparkle gets appalling election-integrity ruling canceled * WorldNetDaily * by Bob Unruh
Source link Judge Sparkle Sooknanan A federal judge in Florida has ruled that a Washington, D.C., judge, the Joe Biden-appointed Sparkle Sooknanan, deliberately violated a court-approved settlement when she arbitrarily
Diane Ravitch's blog
· Jul 13, 2026
Federal Judge Rules Against Trump’s Deal with Justice Department as “Self-Dealing”
Judge Kathleen M. Williams blasted Trump’s 10 billion lawsuit against the Internal Revenue Service and the settlement, which created a 1.776 billion “slush fund” for Trump’s aggrieved allies and granted Trump, his family, and his businesses immunity from IRS audits. Judge Williams also referred Todd Blanche to the Florida Bar Association and the New York []
National Review
· Jun 24, 2026
The Supreme Court Weighs the Right to Sue
The Court took care in three cases to ask where the power to file lawsuits came from.
Western Standard
· Jul 5, 2026
Tax Court judge slams AI-generated fake case law in CRA dispute
A Tax Court judge has issued a sharp warning against the use of artificial intelligence-generated legal citations after a self-represented taxpayer challenged the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) using cases that did not exist.
MS NOW
· Jul 13, 2026
Judge slams Trump-IRS ‘settlement,’ refers attorney for possible disciplinary actions
The president probably thought his 10 billion case against the IRS was over. That was before a federal court found his lawyers acted in “bad faith.” The post Judge slams Trump-IRS ‘settlement,’ refers attorney for possible disciplinary actions appeared first on MS NOW.
NBC News
· Jun 26, 2026
Mistrial declared in trial over deadly Palisades Fire
After two days of deliberations, a federal judge declared a mistrial in the case concerning the origin of the devastating January 2025 fires in Los Angeles. NBC News' Misty Marris explains how the judge reached the mistrial verdict.
The Daily Wire
· Jun 26, 2026
Burned By The Jury: $51B Palisades Fire Trial Goes Up In Smoke
A dramatic mistrial rocked a Los Angeles federal courtroom Friday when jurors threw up their hands in the scorching arson case against the man accused of igniting the deadliest wildfire in California history — and prosecutors are already promising round two. U.S. District Judge Anne Hwang pulled the plug on the trial of Jonathan Rinderknecht, ...
The Advocate
· Jul 4, 2026
Trump officials were so extreme in transgender health case that a Texas judge hit pause
A federal judge in Texas has paused consideration of an emergency request in the Trump administration’s lawsuit against the World Professional Association for Transgender Health after an unusual confrontation between two federal courts over where the fight should proceed, Law Dork first reported.
Coffman Chronicle
· Jun 27, 2026
Palisades Fire Arson Case Ends in Mistrial After Jury Deadlocks
A federal judge declared a mistrial in the arson case against Jonathan Rinderknecht, the man accused of starting the fire that prosecutors say later became the deadly Palisades Fire, leaving one of Los Angeles’ most closely watched wildfire accountability cases unresolved.
Loonie Politics
· Jun 30, 2026
Federal judge denies effort by Trump administration to get New Hampshire’s detailed voter data
A federal judge has dismissed a lawsuit by the Justice Department aimed at compelling New Hampshire to turn over its voter rolls, dealing the Trump administration another setback in its quest for detailed information about the nation’s voters. The ruling from U.S. District Judge Joseph LaPlante found that the request to provide the state’s voter [] The post Federal judge denies effort by Trump administration to get New Hampshire’s detailed voter data appeared first on Loonie Politics.
KTLA 5
· Jun 26, 2026
Mistrial declared in Palisades Fire arson case; jury deadlocked
A judge has declared a mistrial in the case against a former Uber driver accused of sparking the most destructive fire in Los Angeles history. Jurors said they were deadlocked on all three felony counts. Subscribe: https://www.youtube.com/ktla?sub_confirmation=1
Salon
· Jul 13, 2026
“There was never a case”: Judge tosses Trump IRS settlement, accuses admin of settling with itself
Judge Kathleen Williams said that the case flouted constitutional restrictions against self-dealing
Sweden Herald
· Jun 22, 2026
Judge dismisses Trump administration lawsuit against Tim Walz and other Minnesota officials
Judge dismisses Trump administration lawsuit against Tim Walz and other Minnesota officials
The Hill
· Jul 13, 2026
Judge halts Trump's settlement with IRS
A federal judge Monday voided President Trump’s settlement with the Internal Revenue Service (IRS), finding that the lawsuit that served as the hook for the 1.776 billion so-called Anti-Weaponization fund amounted to collusion as the two parties were never truly averse. The ruling from U.S. District Judge Kathleen Williams comes after she was asked to reopen the case intervenors who...
The Daily Signal
· Jun 22, 2026
Judge Who Donated to Immigrant Legal Aid Group Blocks DOJ Immigration Probe of Walz, Ellison
A federal judge in Minnesota, who has donated to an immigrant legal aid group, quashed several federal grand jury subpoenas of documents from Gov. Tim Walz and the mayors of Minneapolis and St. Paul over compliance with immigration enforcement. In a 29-page opinion issued Monday, Chief U.S. District Judge Patrick Schiltz of the District of...
Tampa Free Press
· Jun 22, 2026
Judge Blocks Trump Subpoenas Of Minnesota Leaders: ‘Harass And Retaliate’
A federal judge has blocked the Trump administration’s attempt to subpoena Minnesota Governor Tim Walz and several state and local officials, calling the move an effort to “harass and retaliate against them.” In an unsealed ruling, U.S. District Judge Patrick Schlitz found that the “dominant purpose” of the January subpoenas was to force Minnesota leaders [] Judge Blocks Trump Subpoenas Of Minnesota Leaders: ‘Harass And Retaliate’
Politizoom
· Jun 22, 2026
Skeptical Federal Judges Are Telling Trump and DOJ “Put It In Writing!”
Federal, even state judges have increasingly been slapping Trump’s lawyers including those from the DOJ down. In fact, so much so they are in (too) polite judicial terms telling Team Trump ‘I don’t believe you. You’re promises are worthless – unless you put them in writing AND in a sworn court filing.’ That will give
ArcaMax
· Jul 7, 2026
US judge rejects DOJ subpoena related to 2020 Georgia election
WASHINGTON — A federal judge rejected an effort by the U.S. Justice Department to obtain information on election workers in Fulton County, Georgia, related to the 2020 vote. U.S. District Judge William Ray II quashed a grand jury subpoena for ...
Just the news
· Jun 22, 2026
Supreme Court reinstates murder conviction in 1979 case of missing NYC boy
In a 6-3 ruling, the justices granted an appeal from New York prosecutors who asked the high court to overturn a federal appeals court ruling that overturned the conviction of a man accused in the 1979 case of Etan Patz, a 6-year-old boy who was living in New York City.
Raw Story
· Jul 8, 2026
Trump ordered to hand over E. Jean Carroll's $5M after losing Supreme Court appeal: report
A federal judge has ordered President Donald Trump to release the more than 5 million payment he owes to E. Jean Carroll, a former magazine columnist who sued Trump for sexually abusing and defaming her, according to a new report. CNN reported on Wednesday that Judge Lewis Kaplan told Trump to release the money, along with accrued interest, after the Supreme Court refused to hear Trump's appeal in the case. The payment is part of the civil verdict that found Trump sexually abused Carroll in a department store in 1996, and then defamed her when he became president. Carroll has also secured an 83 million judgment from a jury in her defamation case against Trump. The president has until the end of July to appeal that ruling to the Supreme Court, according to the report. A spokesperson for the Trump administration told CNN in a statement, The American People stand with President Trump as they demand an immediate end to all of the Witch Hunts, including the Democrat-funded travesty of the Carroll Hoaxes. President Trump will keep winning against Liberal Lawfare, as he continues to focus on his mission to Make America Great Again.
We The Media
· Jul 13, 2026
[Photo] 🚨 In the Trump-IRS dispute, a federal judge referred Acting AG Todd Blanche, Associat [...]
In the Trump-IRS dispute, a federal judge referred Acting AG Todd Blanche, Associate AG Stanley Woodward, and President Trump's attorneys to state bar authorities, and invited the initial amici and 35 former federal judges to seek reimbursement of fees.https://x.com/scotus_wire/status/2076705475446370657?s=46
Le Monde
· Jul 10, 2026
Marine Le Pen conviction: 'It's very French to think that preventing one person from running undermines democracy as a whole'
In the far-right leader's appeals trial, judges confirmed, once again, the courts' wariness of intervening too heavily in the political arena.
Topics:
Related coverage for "Judge blasts Trump's IRS lawsuit as filed for 'improper purpose,' recommends attorney discipline": Drudge Report — Judge blasts Trump's IRS lawsuit as filed for 'improper purpose,' recommends attorney discipline.... Fox News — Obama-appointed judge torches Trump admin in latest courtroom showdown, refers attorney for Bar review. Off The Press — Judge says Trump sued IRS for ‘improper purpose,’ refers his lawyer to Florida bar. DNyuz — Trump’s words hurled back at him in scathing ruling as judge refers his lawyer to the bar. Times of India — US judge scraps Trump's IRS settlement deal, says lawsuit sought to 'manipulate judicial process'. PoliticusUSA — Trump's IRS Lawsuit Ruled A Sham, and Judge Orders Sanctions Against His Lawyers . The Epoch Times — Federal Judge Finds Trump IRS Suit Collusive, Improper. KSAT San Antonio — Mistrial declared after jury deadlocks in arson trial over deadly 2025 Palisades Fire in Los Angeles. UPI — Federal judge says Trump sued IRS for ‘improper purpose’. BBC News — US judge voids Donald Trump's $1.8bn settlement with IRS that gave him immunity from tax audits . Catholic World Report — Supreme Court will hear Catholic-backed Jewish religious liberty suit involving ‘finality’ rule. PBS NewsHour — Federal judge halts Trump administration effort to subpoena Walz in immigration enforcement probe. Knewz — Trump admin loses in court as judge shuts down attempts to subpoena Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz, other Dem leaders in immigration crackdown dispute. Washington Examiner — Judge bars Trump from using IRS immunity deal to evade investigation over past tax filings. OpsLens — ‘Big win’: Joe Biden’s Judge Sparkle gets appalling election-integrity ruling canceled * WorldNetDaily * by Bob Unruh. Diane Ravitch's blog — Federal Judge Rules Against Trump’s Deal with Justice Department as “Self-Dealing”. National Review — The Supreme Court Weighs the Right to Sue. Western Standard — Tax Court judge slams AI-generated fake case law in CRA dispute. MS NOW — Judge slams Trump-IRS ‘settlement,’ refers attorney for possible disciplinary actions. NBC News — Mistrial declared in trial over deadly Palisades Fire. The Daily Wire — Burned By The Jury: $51B Palisades Fire Trial Goes Up In Smoke. The Advocate — Trump officials were so extreme in transgender health case that a Texas judge hit pause. Coffman Chronicle — Palisades Fire Arson Case Ends in Mistrial After Jury Deadlocks. Loonie Politics — Federal judge denies effort by Trump administration to get New Hampshire’s detailed voter data. KTLA 5 — Mistrial declared in Palisades Fire arson case; jury deadlocked. Salon — “There was never a case”: Judge tosses Trump IRS settlement, accuses admin of settling with itself. Sweden Herald — Judge dismisses Trump administration lawsuit against Tim Walz and other Minnesota officials. The Hill — Judge halts Trump's settlement with IRS. The Daily Signal — Judge Who Donated to Immigrant Legal Aid Group Blocks DOJ Immigration Probe of Walz, Ellison. Tampa Free Press — Judge Blocks Trump Subpoenas Of Minnesota Leaders: ‘Harass And Retaliate’. Politizoom — Skeptical Federal Judges Are Telling Trump and DOJ “Put It In Writing!”. ArcaMax — US judge rejects DOJ subpoena related to 2020 Georgia election. Just the news — Supreme Court reinstates murder conviction in 1979 case of missing NYC boy. Raw Story — Trump ordered to hand over E. Jean Carroll's $5M after losing Supreme Court appeal: report. We The Media — [Photo] 🚨 In the Trump-IRS dispute, a federal judge referred Acting AG Todd Blanche, Associat [...]. Le Monde — Marine Le Pen conviction: 'It's very French to think that preventing one person from running undermines democracy as a whole'


