'Ruinous Venture' Alligator Alcatraz Closes, But Systemic Abuse of Immigrants Continues

While welcoming Republican Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis' confirmation on Thursday that the immigrant detention center dubbed Alligator Alcatraz has closed, rights advocates also renewed criticism of how immigrants are being treated across the country as President Donald Trump continues his deadly push for mass detention and deportations.The facility in the Everglades opened last summer despite concerns about both human rights and the environmental impact. DeSantis said Thursday that Florida led the way in increasing much-needed detention capacity and working with our federal partners to streamline deportations, removing thousands of the most dangerous criminal aliens from our country.Despite claims from the president and his allies, federal data have shown that most immigrants detained during his second term lack criminal convictions. In addition to flooding US streets with agents from Customs and Border Protection as well as Immigration and Customs Enforcement, Trump has repeatedly demanded that Congress give CBP and ICE more funding.Our detention operations support has led to nearly 30,000 additional deportations, and Florida accounts for more than 40 of all state/local immigration arrests nationwide, DeSantis added Thursday. Alligator Alcatraz has fulfilled this mission. Detainees who are still awaiting deportation have been transferred to other federal facilities, and demobilization efforts are underway.Responding to the governor on social media, Thomas Kennedy of the Florida Immigrant Coalition said: You wasted more than 1 billion of Florida's emergency response fund on a failed PR stunt that hurt people and destroyed families. You should never be anywhere near public office again.As The Associated Press noted Thursday:Immigration advocates said the center’s tents were never safe or humane for holding people. Detainees at the facility have talked about their difficulty accessing lawyers and described poor physical conditions, including worms in the food, toilets that didn't flush, floors flooded with fecal waste, and mosquitoes and other insects everywhere.They described large white tents with rows of and rows of bunk beds surrounded by chain-link cages. The air conditioning could shut off abruptly in the sweltering Florida heat. Detainees could go days without showering or getting prescription medicine.The state and national ACLU as well as Americans for Immigrant Justice (AIJ) had sued over the facility last year.The fact that this site ever existed is a travesty, given the cruelty behind it, horrific conditions, and blatant violations of due process. We challenged the Trump administration and the state of Florida over the facility, and now celebrate its closure, Carmen Iguina González, deputy director for immigration detention with the ACLU's National Prison Project, said Thursday. Keisha Mulfort, deputy executive director and strategy officer of the ACLU of Florida, declared that with its official closure, 'Alligator Alcatraz' seals its reputation as a ruinous venture. This detention center stands as a monument to what happens when a state government abandons its conscience in service of a federal cruelty agenda.The DeSantis administration deliberately built a detention facility in the middle of the Everglades—not despite the harsh conditions, but because of them—and spent over 1 billion of Florida taxpayers' money to do it, she pointed out. That is not governance; that is cruelty dressed up as policy, and complicity dressed up as leadership. In spite of this, hundreds of thousands of Floridians protested, organized, called their legislators, and refused to look away. They made this moment possible, and we should name that clearly: This is what accountability looks like when the government won't hold itself accountable.Mulfort also stressed that as people are transferred to other facilities, the abuses do not disappear—they relocate. She and Iguina González pledged that the state and national ACLU will not stop tracking abuses of immigrants across the country.The nightmarish scene found at 'Alligator Alcatraz' is not wholly unique and reflects systemic patterns of abuse at other ICE detention facilities nationwide, Iguina González said. We remain very concerned that people may be transferred to other sites with sordid and dangerous conditions, and we will continue to monitor this situation.Paul Chavez, director of litigation and advocacy at AIJ, also emphasized that closing this facility is an important step, but the government's obligation to respect due process does not end at the facility gates. Constitutional rights must follow every person wherever they are detained.We remain deeply concerned that people transferred out of this facility will continue to face mistreatment and civil rights violations in other detention centers, he said. Americans for Immigrant Justice will continue to defend due process, offer free legal representation to low-income immigrants, and stand strong with our immigrant neighbors, friends, and their families.After using 1 billion to brutalize immigrants, the concentration camp known as Alligator Alcatraz has been emptied. Its victims still need justice.truthout.org/articles/flo...[image or embed]— UAINE (@mahtowin1.bsky.social) June 22, 2026 at 10:36 PMAs for the environmental impact, The New York Times reported that after the Trump administration announced that detainees had been relocated, Paul J. Schwiep, an attorney for groups suing over Alligator Alcatraz, promised last week to continue the lawsuit against what he called the secret gulag in the Everglades.They hope that they can slink away in the middle of the night without explaining to anyone what they did, why they did it, or how they proposed to clean up the mess that they've made, said Schwiep. And we don't intend to let them get away with it.Ripping the facility as an internment camp, Congressman Maxwell Frost (D-Fla.) similarly asserted on Thursday that the fight isn't over. We need accountability for the billions of taxpayer dollars wasted, the abuse and harm inflicted on detainees, and the damage done to one of Florida's most sacred ecosystems.