Alaska Supreme Court delivers blow to Republicans, rules in favor of 'sham candidate'

The Alaska Supreme Court has delivered the final blow to Republicans' efforts to keep a Senate challenger by the same name as incumbent Sen. Dan Sullivan (R) off the ballot.In a short order handed down Monday, the court affirmed a ruling from a superior court that Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. must appear on the Aug. 18 primary ballot for U.S. Senate.'The only reason he is running is to deceive voters and manipulate Alaska’s election system.'“The 6/26/2026 order of the superior court directing the Division to include appellee Sullivan as a candidate for United States Senator on the primary election ballot is AFFIRMED,” the order said.The court remanded the matter to the Division of Elections to determine how J. Sullivan should be listed on the primary ballot.“A full opinion will be issued at a later date,” concluded the order.Nate Adams, a spokesperson for Sen. Sullivan, released a statement on the ruling: “We’re disappointed in the court’s decision, because, as the sham candidate Dan J. Sullivan’s lawyers made clear in their legal arguments, the only reason he is running is to deceive voters and manipulate Alaska’s election system.”“However, we are encouraged by the fact that the Director of the Division of Elections will be able to use her expertise to differentiate between the Petersburg fraud and the incumbent — Senator Dan Sullivan — to the benefit of Alaska voters,” Adams added.J. Sullivan’s campaign expressed approval of the decision in a statement, saying, “We are grateful for the Alaska Supreme Court’s careful and timely attention to this important expedited matter, and its decision to affirm Judge Matthews’ well-reasoned, thorough order vacating the Division’s unlawful decision to exclude me as a candidate. We expect that the Division will act in full compliance with existing Alaska ballot design law in its preparation of the ballots.”RELATED: Alaska court reinstates Senate candidate sharing incumbent's name A 69-year-old retired teacher, J. Sullivan reportedly registered as a Republican earlier this year and entered the race to oust Sen. Sullivan on May 29, just before the deadline for filing.He has faced accusations from Sen. Sullivan of coordinating with Democrat operatives to sabotage the senator's chances of re-election. Sen. Sullivan told CNN earlier this month that J. Sullivan’s candidacy was effectively a Democrat effort to cheat and confuse voters in order to increase Democrat challenger Mary Peltola's odds of winning.“Democrats recruited a guy by the name of Dan Sullivan. He is a liberal progressive. He’s donated to Peltola,” Sen. Sullivan said.He added, “His campaign logo, his letterhead, his website, all had my campaign logo that I’ve had for 13 years.”In response to J. Sullivan’s candidacy, the National Republican Senatorial Committee and Alaska Republican Party filed complaints with the Federal Election Commission and the state's Division of Elections, respectively.After Alaska Lt. Gov. Nancy Dahlstrom (R) requested an investigation into J. Sullivan’s eligibility, Carol Beecher, the director of the Division of Elections, concluded that J. Sullivan had not filed a genuine good-faith candidacy and instead sought to confuse voters by placing two candidates with nearly identical names on the ballot.J. Sullivan appealed the division's decision to the Superior Court, where Judge Thomas Matthews affirmed that he met all the qualifying criteria set out by the Constitution and therefore Alaska could not impose an additional requirement on his candidacy. The court further concluded that J. Sullivan's alleged motives or political affiliations did not bear on his constitutional eligibility to seek office.The state appealed the decision to the Alaska Supreme Court, which again ruled in favor of J. Sullivan — officially solidifying his place on Alaska's Aug. 18 nonpartisan primary ballot.Like Blaze News? Bypass the censors, sign up for our newsletters, and get stories like this direct to your inbox. Sign up here!